Capital Punishment


This is in justification of my previous blog. As a part of our academic syllabus we have to read Krishna Iyer’s Biography. Having read it when I was in the 2nd year, I cannot say he and his ideas impressed me. He’s considered to be one of the most prominent of judges who added a new dimension to PIL (Sunil Batra’s case). He has further in his book dedicated a whole chapter to Capital Punishment and every time I read that chapter I disagree with every line that has been written. He talks of criminality as a way of behavior, he attributes a person’s crimes to mental illness. Therefore he suggests that criminals must be treated like the ill in a hospital. He has done a lot for prison reforms and for prisoners in general. He is all for human rights and abhors Capital Punishment. He has suggested several means of curbing crime, the same old theories on punitive, retribution and preventive measures. India is a country with a varied assortment of people and an extensive set of sub-labels attached to them, hence there isn’t one particular solution that will apply to all. Each person has to be dealt with individually. When it comes to criminals the judiciary takes into consideration facts surrounding each individual case before passing a judgment and it has been very well established that capital punishment shall be given only in the rarest of rare cases. When Dhanajay’s case was decided and he was sentenced to death, we saw protests of all kinds all over the country asking for his sentence to be commuted. Finally the sentence was carried out.

Gandhi said if we all follow the principle of an eye for an eye, the whole nation would be blind. That is a cliché, which is not applicable in today’s context. Sometimes when a person commits crimes that are heinous, it does fall upon the judiciary not only to do justice to the aggrieved family but also at the same time send the right message to other “prospective criminals” as to what extent the law can go to bring justice to the masses. That being said, you wonder what happens to the family of the convicted? Well the convict didn’t give two hoots when he did what he did, because he thought he wouldn’t be caught. He never planned for the alternative, i.e. what would he do if he were caught. Not once does it cross his mind that not only is he jeopardizing another’s family but also his own. In such circumstances, our sympathies are equally divided between both families. But it is not our emotions that are to decide what course is to be taken. Pardoning once for a crime that is punishable with death will not only instill confidence in the criminal that law is growing soft, but also that he was lucky once and that he can be lucky again.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Google Pixel XL - Review

Image
I had been meaning to change my phone for over a year and it was then that this phone had caught my eye – The Google Pixel XL. I had read so much about it. Found that a lot of people that I am surrounded by had no intentions of getting it. Here is the thing, my sole reason for investing in a gadget has to do with the following: ·         Its price should be within a certain range i.e it should not burn a hole in my wallet. ·         It should at least be guaranteed that the product will be receiving software support for a minimum of 3 years. ·         It should have excellent user interface to make life easy and be a tool for communication as well as relaxation. ·         It should have a good camera. ·         Its accessories must be easily available in the market. It’s with the help of this list that I short list...
Read more

Hey Little Girl... Part I

The little girl aped her elder brother. To her, he was the coolest dude that existed. She was the kid in school who was spoken to because she was so and so’s sister. As a kid she was extremely naïve. Her brother was the quizzer, the topper, the teacher’s pet, the social guy and everybody liked him. She on the other hand was the brat, the swimmer, a teacher’s nightmare, anti social and didn’t want to be liked by anyone. They were polar opposites of each other. Her brother - the witty charmer and She, the *shrugs shoulders* and very impolitely leaving conversation kind of person. Perhaps… the younger version of her envied the ease with which her brother was able to make friends and be at the core of everything that was happening in school. The fact that they were so different and studied in the same school eventually led to teachers constantly comparing them. It wasn’t anything she couldn’t handle. But imagine a little girl always being chastised and all sermons ending with, “why ...
Read more

The Journey

Last weekend was amazing. It began by me traveling solo from Mysore to Madras. I plonked my bags at my best friend's place. Her roomie, she and I headed to Mahabalipuram where we saw the famed sculptures carved out of single boulders. The carvings are pretty intricate and the sight is very pretty but the highlight of the visit was a monkey. While we were leaving the place we saw a troop of monkeys and one of them immediately took a fancy to my friend’s roomie. Now this girl is scared of almost every animal. It became very obvious to her that the monkey was eying the bottle in her hand. She threw it at the monkey. The monkey picked it opened the bottle and gulped the juice and looked so pleased! It was a sight. It does not seem hilarious in print but it was incredibly funny. But before going to Mahablipuram we stopped at the Crocodile Park where I learnt to hold a baby crocodile and also a python. I actually felt the crocodile gulp when I was holding it. The place ...
Read more